Tag: climate change

  • What is MORAL INJURY?

    What is MORAL INJURY?

    I mentioned the idea of Moral Injury to a friend recently. She asked me to summarize it in one word. I said ‘Betrayal’. And I do think that is correct.

    My friend immediately jumped to the idea of PTSD that is a recognized condition by the medical community and effects veterans, but not only veterans. For example, victims of sexual assault also suffer from PTSD. Any serious trauma may result in PTSD. But moral injury and PTSD are not the same thing. 

    I first ran into the words and the idea that moral injury exists on the Veterans for Peace website several years ago. At that time it seemed plausible that such a thing could exist for Vets but I did not pursue it.

    Recently I have seen the term bandied about and addressed in the context of Veterans and how very real it is for them as they struggle with it. Moral injury is not limited to Veterans, but does effect many of them deeply.

    Here are some comments by professionals about Moral Injury:

    Quoted selections from https://moralinjuryproject.syr.edu/about-moral-injury/

    Moral injury is the damage done to one’s conscience or moral compass when that person perpetrates, witnesses, or fails to prevent acts that transgress one’s own moral beliefs, values, or ethical codes of conduct.

    Within the context of military service, particularly regarding the experience of war, “moral injury” refers to the lasting emotional, psychological, social, behavioral, and spiritual impacts of actions that violate a service member’s core moral values and behavioral expectations of self or others (Litz et al., 2009)…

    Drescher et al. (2011) define moral injury as “disruption in an individual’s confidence and expectations about one’s own or others’ motivation or capacity to behave in a just and ethical manner” (p. 9)…

    Shay (2014) emphasizes leadership failure and a “betrayal of what’s right, by a person who holds legitimate authority in a high stakes situation.”

    Silver (2011) speaks of, “a deep soul wound that pierces a person’s identity, sense of morality, and relationship to society” (para. 6)….

    Our basic American culture teaches us “Thou shalt not kill.” The military turns this commandment on its head. That is a betrayal. If one holds deep religious convictions in a Judeo/Christian culture it is a betrayal. If one does not hold such convictions is not really an issue, as the concept is deeply embedded in American culture.

    The concept of the Golden Rule also holds sway. Versions of the Golden Rule occur in all the great religions of the world. The idea of “Do unto others what you would have them do unto you” also permeates cultures and religions then, even if people are not Christians.

    The hierarchical military includes orders to be followed from authoritarian figures at the top, from generals down to all commanding officers, including  the president in the USA who is chief commanding officer of the military. The attitude of obedience to authority is summed up in the phrase, “I got my orders.”

    The Constitution was written making the president chief commander in charge of the military as a bow to George Washington, who was the first U.S. president and also led the troops against all odds in the Revolutionary War.

    U.S. presidents have understood this title and may have a military background or may not. They have deferred to military advisors and have sought the approval the U.S. Constitution calls for, the approval of Congress to go to war.

    For example, after Pearl Harbor the U.S. Congress immediately declared war after what had been a reluctant public in debate after WW I because it was supposed to be “the war to end all wars.”

    After WWII an example was the Korean “war” that was not approved by Congress and was called a “Police Action” or “Intervention” because so many had been killed, Americans and others, in WWII: It was limited to North and South Korea and called the “Korean Conflict.”

    It is of note that General Dwight D. Eisenhower became President Eisenhower and is famous for his statement regarding the military industrial complex:

    On January 17, 1961, in this farewell address, President Dwight Eisenhower warned against the establishment of a “military-industrial complex”:

    In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military-industrial complex. The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist. We must never let the weight of this combination endanger our liberties or democratic processes. We should take nothing for granted. Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry can compel the proper meshing of the huge industrial and military machinery of defense with our peaceful methods and goals, so that security and liberty may prosper together.[8]

    Two items of note about this statement are: First, it was  originally written as the military-industrial-congressional complex.

    In the penultimate draft of his final address, President Eisenhower warned of the “growing influence of the military-industrial-congressional complex” but decided to strike the word “congressional” because he thought it was “not fitting. . . for a President to criticize Congress.”  Wm. Hartung

    Second, while the statement rightly targets the arms industry, it serves also as a warning about corporate takeover in general and so includes the oil industry, weapons industry, and AI. Also it now applies to the media, especially with the new consolidation of Warner Bros. and Paramount.

    In fact as we now have the digital revolution, and as part of that the AI revolution, it has been correctly suggested that the phrase be the digital-military-industrial- complex.

    Here is a another part of Eisenhower’s January 17, 1951 speech:

    Down the long lane of the history yet to be written America knows that this world of ours, ever growing smaller, must avoid becoming a community of dreadful fear and hate, and be, instead, a proud confederation of mutual trust and respect.

    In contrast we now have  a president who worships militarism and controls Congress. He continually uses fear and hate to try to intimidate people. And he did not ask Congress for approval of the current Iran war, which has exploded into a Middle East war. It is a war about Big Oil fossil fuel and the money the oil companies have been making for years. They are now making even more money while the U.S. murders Iranian officials and pretends to seek peace with Iran. But whoops, every effort is scuttled (Trump blames Iran of course) and the oil companies benefit from raised oil prices for the consumer at the pump.

    He has also attacked Cuba and cut them off from supplies they need to survive, especially oil. Without oil they cannot make the electricity necessary for not only for light but for hospitals, etc.

    The arms industry is also making a lot of money from the Iran war, if not as much as the oil industry that continues to help poison the air.

    The Trump regime ignores the fact that the U.S. military is the greatest polluter on earth with its many military bases worldwide. That’s CO2 (carbon) and also high in methane gas emissions. Then there’s PFAS that poisons the water.

    The fight against the war machine and the fight to save the planet is the same fight.  — Abby Martin

    From the film:

    Earth’s Greatest Enemy, a film by Abby Martin.

    And what does this have to do with moral injury? Isn’t that only for people like veterans who have suffered that in war?

    NO, it is for you and for me.

    Trump makes a practice of defying the U.S. Constitution with his “executive orders,” his constant lies and coverups. One obvious example is his hand in the coverup of the Epstein files as proof comes forward that he was directly involved. Also his campaign promises for the 2024 elections: he hasn’t kept any. He has betrayed those who voted for him along with betraying the U.S. Constitution. His presidency is “a community of dreadful fear and hate ” at every turn.

    While initially applied to the military, moral injury is now identified in diverse populations, including health professionals, lawyers, public servants, and teachers. 

    I include ACTIVISTS in that list. While we may have suffered moral injury in the past in our quest for peace and justice, it has never been to the extent of the betrayal by the Trump regime along with Israel and the genocide in Gaza that continues. Our government has supported that genocide with arms and with money since the beginning. So the Democrats and Biden are as guilty as the Trump regime in that regard.

    On October 7, 2026 the media “celebrated” three years of this now expanded war and daily we continue to suffer moral injury as Congress continues to send money and weapons to Israel and the media endlessly sends us photos of a bombed-out Gaza and reports about how the people of Gaza who are left are starving. I am not saying they should not send these reports. But they drive home daily the moral injury that Gaza is as genocide, murdering the people of Palestine for their religion and culture and because Israel wants their land.

    On the Oct 7th anniversary of the war in Iran I watched a video from the survivors of the bombing by Hamas in Israel that started the war. They are still mourning the loss of family and friends: around 1200 killed. That is terrible for them. To them it is perhaps not understandable that Gaza gets all the attention because they do not see the causes of harassment and persecution of Palestinians by Israel since at least 1978 and the yoke of settler colonialism for 100 years. They mourn their beloved dead as the Palestinians mourn theirs in a natural response.

    Hamas should not have bombed Israel. But the many years of persecution and harassment wore on the Palestinians. So on the other side does the Hamas bombing justify the murder of thousands and thousands of Gazans? Of bombing their hospitals along with their homes? Killing healthcare workers? journalists? children?

    It does not. And that too is a moral injury to see both the Democrats and Republicans in Congress go along with three years of this war and continue to send support to Israel. It is true that there is finally some movement by Congress regarding the funding, but the Trump regime is still trying to continue support for Israel’s war in the Middle East that includes the bombing of Lebanon and Syria by Israel. It includes the involvement of other Middle Eastern countries in an expansion of what has become a war that spreads farther than the closing of the Strait of Hormuz to the U.S. and other countries for transport of oil and other necessary items including fertilizer for  food.

    Here is an extended part of Eisenhower’s January 17, 1951 speech:

    Down the long lane of the history yet to be written America knows that this world of ours, ever growing smaller, must avoid becoming a community of dreadful fear and hate, and be, instead, a proud confederation of mutual trust and respect.

    Such a confederation must be one of equals. The weakest must come to the conference table with the same confidence as do we, protected as we are by our moral, economic, and military strength. That table, though scarred by many past frustrations, cannot be abandoned for the certain agony of the battlefield.

    Disarmament, with mutual honor and confidence, is a continuing imperative. Together we must learn how to compose difference, not with arms, but with intellect and decent purpose.

    Trump and the Trump regime ignore the majority of the American people as Trump’s popularity in the polls shrinks and his personal behavior becomes more erratic. The money continues to flow to the corporate millionaires and billionaires along with Trump and his family in a betrayal of the people who suffer, getting poorer in an economy that funnels the money to an elite group of wealthy people and is controlled by a neofascist government that ignores human rights and U.S. law. Their system unravels laws that created  organizations established to protect and aid the people and to promote equality. Examples are the destruction of the Environmental Protection Agency and the Voting Act and the withdrawal of Medicare and Medicaid for many as important examples that nonetheless barely scratch the surface of the Trump regime’s attempts to destroy democracy in America.

    In the meantime moral injury continues in the new war in the Middle East that most Americans oppose. The endless wars that the Trump regime inherited continue in spite of his lies about bringing peace and with the addition of the Iran/Middle East war. In contrast to the wars is the cutting of funding U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) that provided the lead international humanitarian and development arm of the U.S. government. Funding was cut on July 1, 2025.

    I need to mention—although it is well documented online—the outrageous  amounts of money being granted to ICE whose members continue illegal arrests of immigrants who are then put in crowded detention centers under life-threatening conditions and deported. The whole system of arrest, detention, and deportation is very expensive. The laws governing immigration need to be abolished and new guidelines and laws established that cover immigration fairly and allow for immigrants of all colors instead of the current racist system that does not recognize the many positive contributions they have made to our economy and culture.

    The Betrayal continues.

    Sources

    * https://moralinjuryproject.syr.edu/about-moral-injury/

    Some information about Moral Injury is from the writings of Amy Blumenshine, antiwar activist and deacon in the Lutheran church.

    US Judicial Failure to Uphold the Law Against Genocide:

    Nine Minnesotan taxpayers tell what happened when they tried taking legislative and executive branch “leaders” to court for their support of U.S. funding for Israel’s genocide. 

    By Minnesotan Taxpayers Against Genocide / Consortium News /September 14, 2026


     

  • DeTRUMPification, by Susu Jeffrey

    DeTRUMPification, by Susu Jeffrey

    DeTRUMPification

    By Susu Jeffrey / Original to Wings of Change / September 28, 2026

    All the world’s his stage from the moment he salutes. Wait! By custom only those  who served in the military have the right to salute. Trump’s soft salute lacks the snap of someone without bone spurs, his draft dodger doctor excuse for avoiding Vietnam. It’s all bombast, the little man behind the curtain. But what a show—filled with sound and fury and no intermission.

    Trump is an abstraction in his red, white and blue power costume. It looks like the real thing but he’s messing up his lines. Unless you name the Kennedy Center after me I’ll East-Wing-it.

    Untitled standing figure (1980) by Japanese post World War 2 artist Nobuaki Kojima (1935-2024)

    The East Wing used to be the First Lady’s, the women’s wing. The president will not share his throne. His interchangeable partners flow around him like do-si-do dancers. Presented as a businessman his patent consistency is the six bankruptcies carried into his two-term head of state financial decline. Whoever believed one could tank America’s first world’s 250-year credit in just six years?

    The Prime Minister of Canada called Trump “the king of bankruptcies.” Unfortunately for America the president with his reverse Midas touch has glommed his bad luck onto the national treasury.

    “I Have Made Peace”

    “While others have spoken of peace I have made peace,” Trump professed to the United Nations General Assembly (9/22/2026). Putin has his ongoing “special military operation” in Ukraine since the seizure of Crimea in 2014. “War” is not happening when it’s called something else. There are 65 active conflicts on Earth today not to mention the existential contest for the future called Climate Change.

    Trump has engaged in foreign interventions in Iran, Yemen, Somalia, Nigeria, Syria, Iraq, Venezuela and on fishermen in the Caribbean Sea and Eastern Pacific. Is he afraid of a no AUMF (Authorization for Use of Military Force) congressional vote or is he afraid of black and brown people? A classic bully, Trump orders his minions to attack those who threaten him. Internationally America is losing all our friends except Israel. Israel!?—the Hitler of Gaza. Everything Hitler did was “legal.”

    What is WRONG with Trump?

    Trump’s mother was absent with illness after her last pregnancy when he was two years old, a crucial time for toddlers. His father taught him that a “killer” is a winner, opposite a loser. When he was 13, the charmless youth was exiled to New York Military Academy (north  of West Point on the Hudson), a very small, expensive, so-so academic all-boys (at that time) boarding college-prep school, grades 7-12. He reportedly loved it and more-or-less majored in “leadership” and sports. One Trump biographer called his military school “a five-year lesson on how to be a bully.” He was not a “popular” cadet. In summer when he was home from school Trump’s mother often vacationed in her Scottish homeland.

    All three of Trump’s wives were fashion models. Appearance is primary in his social/business world just as verbal communication has priority over paperwork. Trump had three children with his first wife and one each with wives two and three; he now has 11 grandchildren. Don Jr. has five children with his first wife; Ivanka, three children; Eric, two; and Tiffany, one. The greater family reportedly convenes in available numbers for sporting or political events.

    As if three wives, five kids, and 11 grandchildren weren’t sufficient legacy Trump is pursuing more concrete memorials like the Kennedy Performing Arts Center, an outsized Arc de Triomph and golf clubs and Trump towers in vacation spots. Trump seems to be locking-in his legacy as mortality looms. However, buildings and landscapes do change names like the Bruce Vento Nature Sanctuary in St. Paul, named for the late environmental congressman, now called Wakan Tipi, Dakota for sacred habitation or home.

    Meanwhile Trump has installed his son-in-law, Jared Kushner, previously a millionaire developer with a father imprisoned for illegal campaign contributions, tax evasion and witness tampering, now a billionaire United States Special Envoy for Peace—in the highest level of international money and politics.

    Envoy for “peace?” The U.S. is at war. Russia is also at war. The “great powers” are trashing the Earth when the universal battle is saving the planet from runaway global heating.

    Antiphrasis

    Antiphrasis means saying the opposite of what is meant.

    How did the narcissist Donald J. Trump get elected, move into the White House that he called “a dump,” shred the Constitution, cow the legislature, pack the Supreme Court and survive three assassination attempts? Unplug Trump who has become a rogue Ai agent.

    VOTE!


    SOURCES

    The Mystery of Mary Trump

    Ivana Trump

    Learn more about Donald Trump’s 5 children: Donald Jr., Ivanka, Eric, Tiffany and Barron

    A Guide to Trump’s Second-Term Military Strikes and Actions

    List of United States military schools and academies

    The Dangerous Case of Donald Trump:  27 Psychiatrists and Mental Health Experts Assess a President by Bandy Lee, M.D., M.Div., Organizer of the Yale “Duty to Warn” Conference academy-post/

    The Strange Case of Donald J. Trump: A Psychological Reckoning, Dan P. McAdams

    Donald Trump’s Prenup with Marla Maples Leaks, Reveals His ‘Optimistic’ Financial Figures

    Trump’s ‘draconian’ prenup with Marla Maples revealed: No support for Tiffany if she joined military or Peace Corps

    What to know about Donald Trump’s 11 grandchildren

    All About Donald Trump’s 11 Grandkids

    How Jared Kushner’s Bold Bets In The Middle East Made Him A Billionaire

    Jared Kushner’s net worth grew 1,440% since 2009 — 9 times more than the average US household. Here’s what drove the gap



    These times have been given many names, harrowing, overwhelming, end of America, end times  and more…. Midterms are coming up in 4 weeks. Vote. And do not let Trump’s threats of ICE, etc. drive you from polling places. Better yet find out where you can vote early in your area and do so.

    Wings of Change offers an often unique slant on the news and the state of the nation and global politics, sometimes from experts, and always from truth-telling people. Rise Up Times is still on social media with local news and news of global and national demonstrations and information on Facebook and Instagram and other social media including a Rise Up Times and also a Sue Ann Martinson Facebook page.

    Join WingsofChange.me today. Here is the link to subscribe. No fees. Donations welcome.

  • COP30: Handwringing at the UN Climate Talks, by Inside Climate News

    COP30: Handwringing at the UN Climate Talks, by Inside Climate News

    DONATE TO WINGS OF CHANGE TODAY

    Editor’s Note: Many analyses summarizing the COP30 Climate conference have appeared by mainstream corporate media and by others. This analysis is not mainstream corporate media. I found the analysis of the internal workings of the conference and paticularly the role of the U.S. even though there was no formal delegation this year, as Trump refused to attend and to send a delegation.

    Go behind the scenes with executive editor Vernon Loeb and climate science reporter Bob Berwyn as they break down the key outcomes of COP30. COP30 has wound down in Belém, Brazil – the U.N. climate change conference marked this year by Indigenous rights demonstrations, an actual fire, and not a lot of movement on global climate action. Before leaving Belém, Bob explains what happened at COP30, both within the formal proceedings and adjacent to them; how American influence was woven into the process; and what to look for leading up to next year’s COP31 in Turkey.


    The INC video above does not include mention of the announcement of this Initiative:

    Colombia and The Netherlands Announce First Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Initiative …

    The Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative

    Belém, Brazil – As COP30 negotiations draw to an end, and the most recent text released this morning makes no mention of fossil fuels, the Governments of Colombia and the Netherlands show leadership by announcing they will co-host the First International Conference on the Just Transition Away from Fossil Fuels. The announcement was made by the Minister of Environment of Colombia, Irene Vélez Torres, and the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Climate Policy of the Netherlands, Sophie Hermans, during a high-level press conference in Belém.

    The conference will advance international cooperation on transitioning away from fossil fuel extraction.

    Two of many news reports on the results of COP30.

    BBC COP30: Five key takeaways from a deeply divisive climate …

    Many countries were livid when COP30 in Belém, Brazil ended on Saturday with no mention of the fossil fuels that have heated up the atmosphere.




    Subscribe! Sign Up for Updates

    FREE SPEECH

    Join Wings of Change! It’s only the beginning as we still have so much work to do as many activists and organizations make plans for the upcoming years. Wings of Change is pleased and passionate about being a part of that work through education, information, and inspiration.

    Updates Sign-up

    Never miss news articles on current issues  and Sue Ann’s blog! Sign up here for an email notice of new posts from Wings of Change.

  • DN! COP30 Report: The Amazon Tipping Point, Fossil Fuel Phaseout, Climate-induced Migration

    DN! COP30 Report: The Amazon Tipping Point, Fossil Fuel Phaseout, Climate-induced Migration

    The Race to Save the Amazon: Top Brazilian Scientist Says Rainforest Is at “Tipping Point”

    Amy Goodman interviews scientist Carlos Nobre / Democracy Now! / November 20, 2025

    AMY GOODMAN : As we broadcast from the COP30 climate summit in Belém, Brazil, we are joined by one of Brazil’s most prominent scientists, [Nobel Prize winner] Carlos Nobre, who says the Amazon now produces more carbon emissions than it removes from the atmosphere, moving closer to a “tipping point” after which it will be impossible to save the world’s largest rainforest. “We need urgently to get to zero deforestation in all Brazilian biomes, especially the Amazon,” he argues. (See full transcript below.)

     

    StoryNov 20, 2025 Democracy Now!

    Brazilian Indigenous Minister Sônia Guajajara on Fossil Fuel Phaseout, Bolsonaro’s Conviction & More

    SÔNIA GUAJAJARA: [translated] It’s always a challenge. It’s really — it’s not simple. It’s hard, because there is a dispute, a big one, with the economic sectors, so that these changes do not happen. So we need to make sure that agreements done at COP and commitments done at COP can tackle this, because the world knows the impact that oil exploitation, fossil fuels does, the risk of us achieving the point of no return, but these sectors, the economic sectors, need to understand this is an emergency. So we need to have, like, a clear decision here in this conference to stop depending on fossil fuel.

    _____________________

    StoryNov 20, 2025  Democracy Now!

    Climate Crisis Displaces 250 Million Over a Decade While U.S. & Other Polluting Nations Close Borders

    “This is not abstract,” Nikki Reisch, director of climate and energy at the Center for International Environmental Law, says of climate-induced migration. “This is about real lives. It’s about survival. It’s about human rights and dignity, and, ultimately, about justice.”

    Trump’s Response to COP30

    Trump sends no formal U.S. delegation at COP30: Here is Trump’s response as he is determined to destroy the planet and continues his own version of genocide against the Least Developed Countires (LTC) that are most affected by global warming caused by fossil fuels. Meanwhile 80 nations at COP30 have signed on to plan to phase-out fossil fuels.

    Trump Saudi Arabia© Evan Vucci

    The Trump administration announced on Thursday new oil drilling off the California and Florida coasts for the first time in decades, advancing a project that critics say could harm coastal communities and ecosystems, as President Donald Trump seeks to expand U.S. oil production.

    More than 80 countries at Cop30 join call for roadmap to fossil fuel phaseout

    Countries from Africa, Asia, Latin America, Pacific and Europe plead for transition to be central outcome of talks.

    Transcript
    This is a rush transcript. Copy may not be in its final form.

    AMY GOODMAN: This is Democracy Now!, democracynow.org. We’re broadcasting at the U.N. climate summit, COP30, here in the Brazilian city of Belém, the gateway to the Amazon rainforest. I’m Amy Goodman, with Nermeen Shaikh. As we broadcast, there’s a protest right behind us by the Loss and Damage Youth Coalition, where they are holding a banner that reads, “From opinion to obligation, respond to loss and damage.”

    NERMEEN SHAIKH: We end today’s show with one of Brazil’s most prominent scientists, Dr. Carlos Nobre. He’s a senior researcher at the Institute of Advanced Studies at the University of São Paulo and co-chair of the Scientific Panel for the Amazon. He’s a lead author of the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, or IPCC, that won a Nobel Peace Prize in 2007 for its reports on global warming.

    AMY GOODMAN: For decades, Carlos Nobre has been warning the Amazon rainforest is being pushed beyond the tipping point. The Amazon rainforest is almost as large as the contiguous United States.

    Carlos Nobre, welcome to Democracy Now! It’s an honor to be in your presence. You have been warning for quite some time, and now it’s getting more serious than ever. What is the tipping point? And for a lay audience around the world, explain to us why the biome of the Amazon rainforest is so important for the world.

    CARLOS NOBRE: Good morning. Thank you very much.

    Yes, I’ve been working for 43 years with the Amazon. I was the first scientist, 1990, 1991, publishing a science article saying if we continue with very high deforestation, the Amazon would cross the tipping point. But that was 1990, ’91, 36 years ago. Now the Amazon is very close to the tipping point.

    Why do we say that? Because from the Atlantic to Bolivia, Peru and Colombia, this is 2.5 million square kilometers. The whole forest, close to 7 million square kilometers, but this southern portion, very close to tipping point. The dry season is four to five weeks’ length here — in 45 years, one week per decade. It was three, four months, but with rain during the dry season. Now it’s four to five months, 20, 30% drier, two, three degrees warmer. And also, tree mortality has increased a lot in these areas. In the southeastern Amazon, south of where we are, the forest has become a carbon source. It’s losing more carbon than removing.

    So, if we continue — deforestation is about 18%, degradation 30% — if we reach 20, 25% deforestation, global warming close to two degrees, we cross permanently the tipping point. We are going to lose up to 70% of the Amazon within 30 to 50 years. If we continue with global warming, deforestation, we reach the tipping point by 2040. So, by 27 — 2100, we’re going to lose 70% of the Amazon. We’ll release more than 250 billion tons of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere, making it impossible to maintain the global warming at 1.5 degrees. We are going to lose the highest biodiversity in the planet. So, terrible.

    And also, the Amazon recycles water so well that about 45% of the water vapor that comes from the Atlantic Ocean, transported by the trade winds, goes to the south of the Amazon and feeds more than 50% of rainfall on the tropical savanna south of the Amazon, so — and also the Atlantic rainforest. So, it’s really essential. If we lose the Amazon, not only the Amazon forest will disappear, but the tropical savanna, as well.

    NERMEEN SHAIKH: If you could also talk, Dr. Nobre — in addition to increasing heat and the dryness that you talked about, you’ve also said that livestock grazing is a form of ecological pollution. Now, Brazil is the world’s second-largest producer of beef. If you could talk about what the impact of cattle ranching has been on this deforestation of the Amazon?

    CARLOS NOBRE: Yes, of course. I mean, 90% of the deforestation in the lowlands in the Amazon in Brazil is related to cattle ranches. And when we compute, Brazil is the only country in the world where 70% of fossil fuel emissions, greenhouse gas emissions, come from land use change, about 70% of emissions, 40% deforestation. And about 20, 25% of this comes from agriculture, but mostly for cattle ranches. Particularly, the cattle emits a lot of methane, so — all ruminants. So, we say 55% of emissions in Brazil related to livestock, you know, the deforestation for cattle ranches and also the cattle emitting methane.

    So, really, we need urgently to get to zero deforestation in all Brazilian biomes, especially the Amazon, and also merging to the so-called regenerative livestock. Regenerative livestock. We have about 15% in Brazil of regenerative livestock, and very little. The regenerative livestock makes — reduces a lot emissions by livestock.

    NERMEEN SHAIKH: And, you know, in Brazil, as you well know, Brazil is one of the world’s largest agricultural exporters, which means the alternative that you mentioned may compensate, but presumably it would be a massive economic loss to Brazil if their agricultural production were to go down. But as you were mentioning earlier, though, there has been a commitment by countries here to work on a roadmap to get to zero deforestation by 2030. So there is an agreement there, whereas there is not a majority of countries signing up to the roadmap to phasing out fossil fuels. So, if you could just talk about, I mean, the countries that are, in part, dependent on agricultural exports, what would it mean to diminish cattle ranching? And, I mean, you’ve become, in fact, vegetarian as a result of this.

    CARLOS NOBRE: Oh, listen, mostly livestock average productivity is very low. Brazil has about 1.5 heads of cattle per hectare. This is very little. Brazil has about 3.2 million square kilometers, mostly livestock and also agricultural. So, regenerative livestock will have three to five heads of cattle per hectare, reduce emission, and also the regenerative agriculture and livestock is much more resilient to the climate extremes. For instance, last year, Brazil had a record-breaking drought in the Amazon tropical savanna, Cerrado, and a record-breaking number — decline of agricultural productivity. So, therefore, Brazil can continue being a tremendous high producer of meat, agriculture, soy grains, using not 3.2 million square kilometers, but maximum 2 million square kilometers.

    AMY GOODMAN: I want to ask you a question about climate science. You have said that it’s a mystery to you, the country which invested the most in climate science, a country with the largest number of climate scientists and very few who deny climate change, which contributed the most to the IPCC report — how is it possible this country elected a climate denier? And we’re talking about the United States. But talk about the significance of the billions of dollars being removed from science research in the United States, and the effect that has all over the world?

    CARLOS NOBRE: Well, that’s a very good question, because, in fact, I mean, I create a name, because all tipping points that we know in the climate, more than 20, they are all associated with ecological, biological, hydrological, ocean-related tipping points. But I’m thinking how the world, in democracies, we are creating a, quote, quote-unquote, “a social/political tipping point,” which is — it’s not only in the U.S. In many countries in the world, democracies, we are electing more and more populist politicians — U.S. President Trump, Argentina President Milei. Brazil elected a former president, Bolsonaro, totally climate denier. Deforestation increased a lot in those four years. That’s happening all over the planet. So, this is a — I even gave a name in the West. I said this social/political tipping point is the “trumping point.” Why we are, in democracies — as you mentioned, the country with the top science on climate change, U.S., always, for decades — why U.S. democracy electors are electing a climate-denier president? This is very serious.

    NERMEEN SHAIKH: And you’ve said, Dr. Nobre — I mean, it’s remarkable, as you said, with these right-wing governments, being led in part by Donald Trump, the fact that this roadmap to deforestation was agreed. You’ve said that COP30 is a critical meeting of — a critical climate summit. Explain why, and what you hope is going to come out of this. It’s formally concluding tomorrow, but it regularly goes beyond that date.

    CARLOS NOBRE: Yes, that’s a very good point, because all of us scientists, we say this COP30 has to be very important, I mean, as important as Paris Agreement, as important as COP26, when all countries agree in reducing emissions. But now we have to accelerate reducing emissions.

    Yesterday, we, the Planetary Science Pavilion people, we hand-delivered our declaration to all negotiators, and I hand-delivered to President Lula, as well. We say, in addition to zero deforestation in all biomes, tropical forests by 2030, we have to accelerate reducing of emission by fossil fuels. We say, ideally, zero fossil fuel emissions by 2040, no longer than 2045 — no questions, because the temperature is reaching 1.5 degrees within five to 10 years permanently. If we only get to net-zero emissions by 2050, we may reach two degrees and even more. It will be a tragedy, an ecocide for the planet.

    And when I presented this document to President Lula, he said also — four times, he said — I was in a meeting with him. He said, “This has to be the most important COP of all COPs.” Let’s hope, in two days now, countries will agree not only zero deforestation in all tropical forests by 2030, but zero fossil fuel emissions —

    AMY GOODMAN: Ten seconds.

    CARLOS NOBRE: — by 2040.

    AMY GOODMAN: We want to thank you so much, Carlos Nobre, leading Brazilian scientist, world-renowned climatologist, senior researcher at the Institute of Advanced Studies at the University of São Paulo, co-chair of the Scientific Panel for the Amazon, where we are right now. We’re in Belém, the gateway of the Amazon. I’m Amy Goodman, with Nermeen Shaikh.

    The original content of this program is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. Please attribute legal copies of this work to democracynow.org. Some of the work(s) that this program incorporates, however, may be separately licensed. For further information or additional permissions, contact us.



    Rise Up Times is entirely reader supported.

    In this critical time in hearing the voices of truth is all the more important although censorship and attacks on truth-tellers are common. Support WingsofChange.me as we bring you important articles and journalism beyond the mainstream corporate media on the Wings of Change website and Rise Up Times on social media  Access is alway free, but if you would like to help:
    A donation of $25 or whatever you can donate will bring you articles and opinions from independent websites, writers, and journalists as well as a blog with the opinions and creative contributions by myself and others. 

     Subscribe: Join us on Wings of Change

    Note: to reach the Wings of Change website quickly type the full .url in the search engine of your choice: wingsofchange.me

    Sue Ann Martinson, Writer, Editor Wings of Change

  • The Politics of Change: Why Global Democracy Needs Dissent, by Roland Bleiker

    The Politics of Change: Why Global Democracy Needs Dissent, by Roland Bleiker

    The Politics of Change: Why Global Democracy Needs Dissent

    By Roland Bleiker. Originally published in “Dynamics of Dissent” Georgetown Journal of International Affairs. Summer/Fall 2008 pp. 33-39. Used with permission of the author.

    Editors Note: This article was written before the genocide by Israel in Palestine but casts perspective on the global dissent around the genocide. It also invites considering the global significance of the No King’s Day demonstrations and other national acts of dissent in relation to the current U.S. administration. In addition, it addresses the issues of inclusion and dissent around climate change as paramount while the annual global COP conference in regard to the ongoing climate crisis is currenly taking place in Brazil.

    Dissidents are celebrated as heroes when they struggle against oppressive political regimes.1

    In democracies, however, dissent is all too often seen as a dangerous force that undermines stability, order, and the rule of law.

    Vilified as they are, dissidents nevertheless play an important role in democratic practice. This paper explores what may well be one of the key challenges of our day: extending democratic ideals to the global realm. Doing so is essential because processes of globalization increasingly undermine the traditional realm of democratic participation: the national state. Citizens’ daily lives are influenced by political, financial, and cultural forces that transgress state boundaries. For example, the effects of greenhouse gas emissions are global, even though most of them are caused by a relatively small number of developed countries. Any solution to the ensuing problems of climate change, from droughts to rising sea levels, can only be found through a concerted and coordinated global effort. People in all parts of the world should thus have a say in how the related issues are addressed, but many global institutions, international organizations, and multinational companies are neither transparent nor accountable to a democratic public.

    Extending democracy to the global level is, of course, a difficult task. Some very limited efforts are already in place. The UN, for instance, offers a forum in which states can debate issues of global concern. Some urge the UN to add an elected and globally repre-sentative assembly to its existing struc-ture, but such suggestions are a long way from being realized in practice.2 Even if they are adopted, a far more difficult underlying problem remains: Global democratic institutions must be embesdded in a global regulatory framework with the power to implement decisions if they are to play the same role as their state-based counterparts. Such a scenario is highly unlikely in the foreseeable future. If democracy is to have meaning and significance at the global level, then a more fundamental rethinking of the very notion of democracy is required. This essay recommends how one might productively approach some aspects of the challenges at stake.

    I first suggest, somewhat counter-intuitively, that dissident movements can make a positive contribution to the search for global democracy. This is pre-cisely because dissent disturbs existing political orders and the privileges they mask. I sustain this position through a brief engagement with the anti-globalization movement, focusing solely on the protest element of the movement. Anarchical, disruptive, and at times violent, the protest element is certainly the most contentious aspect of the movement. It also illustrates, however, how dissent can challenge institutionalized relations of power and, by doing so, generate public debate and perhaps even enforce a certain level of accountability otherwise impossible in a global realm that lacks viable democratic institutions. Arguing so is not to deny the importance of democratic institutions but to stress that without periodic political challenges, existing forms of governance tend to establish, uphold, and mask practices of domination and exclusion.

    The second point I wish to make is a conceptual reinforcement of the first: democracy must be viewed not only as a set of institutions, but also as an evolving attitude. Many theorists suggest that our conceptualization of democracy should go beyond institutional models and into a procedural realm.3 William Connolly, for instance, fosters a democratic ethos based not on fundamental principles but on the need to disturb these principles. Connolly is afraid that any institutional order that remains unchallenged poses a serious obstacle to a truly transnational democratic disposition. He thus advocates a “democratic politics of disturbance” and, far-fetched as it may seem, promotes respect for “multiple constituencies honoring different moral sources.” 4

    Globalization and the Changing Nature of Dissent

    Dissent is, at first sight, an unlikely ally in the search for global democracy. More specifically, the anti-globalization movement seems to highlight the problems of globalization rather than the search for democratic solutions.

    For one, the movement is disorganized, chaotic, and seemingly unable to come up with any coherent and positive strategy. Among the diverse and often polarized groups of the movement we find feminists, environmentalists, steel-workers, anarchists, farmers, and students. Their goals are far too diverse to produce a common agenda, and violent elements of the movement, even if they are in the minority, often derail a protest event that was meant to be peaceful. Skepticism is thus warranted about the extent to which such a chaotic dissident movement can make a positive contribution to global democracy. But is this skepticism really justified? A closer look reveals a surprisingly different picture.

    A crisis of legitimacy stems from the weak democratic accountability of the state and multilateral institutions.

    The movement’s first major event that attracted global media coverage was the so-called “Battle for Seattle,” which resulted in four days of massive street demonstrations against a December 1999 World Trade Organization (WTO) meeting in Seattle, Washington. Many commentators consider this event, which brought together some 40,000 demonstrators of different backgrounds and political persuasions, a watershed event in the public awakening to a global consciousness. They speak of an event that symbolized the world’s discontent with the spread of globalization and with policies that seemingly promoted free trade and corporate greed over the inter-ests of average people and the environment.5 Numerous other protest events followed in the years to come, including demonstrations against meetings of the World Economic Forum, the Interna-tional Monetary Fund (IMF), and the World Bank.

    The substantive claims of the anti-globalization movement are highly con-troversial. Its main targets are key liberal economic institutions of the world economy: the World Bank, the IMF, and the WTO. Protesters strongly lament the lack of democratic accountability within these organizations. The influential voice of journalist Vandana Shiva, who argues that the WTO is enforcing an “anti-people, anti-nature decision to enable corporations to steal the world’s harvests through secretive, undemocratic structures and processes,” is representative of many anti-globalization protesters.6 Many scholars and commentators dismiss such a pessimistic understanding of globalization. Instead, we often hear of the benign story of Western democracy and free market principles bringing progress and economic growth to previously undeveloped parts of the world.7

    The reality lies somewhere in between these extremes, but the message that the anti-globalization movement seeks to convey is perhaps less important than the manner in which it has managed to capture public attention. Since many people around the globe see street protests as the only opportunity to express their opinions, a crisis of legitimacy stems from the weak democratic accountability of the state and multilateral institutions. The anti-globalization movement demonstrates what Joan Bondurant identified as liberal thought’s primary flaw: “the failure to provide techniques of action for those critical occasions when the machinery of democratic government no longer functions to resolve large-scale, overt conflict.”8

    But the situation is not nearly as gloomy as anti-globalization movements claim it to be. The very fact that we are aware of this movement and of its various grievances demonstrates that globalization has provided populations with a new method of participating in political debates. There are at least two reasons for this transformation of dissent.

    First, recent technological innovations have provided dissidents with tools to organize and coordinate their actions. Many of the protesters that went to Seattle, for example, were united through e-mail correspondences and a variety of websites that organized resistance strategies, thus making the movement far less disorganized and aimless than it initially seemed. Mobile phones helped coordinate on-the-ground actions, which resulted in alliances between highly unlikely protest segments. In Seattle, again, the labor and environmental movements joined with anarchists and church groups to present a common front.9

    Second, global media networks have fundamentally transformed the nature and methodology of dissent. Media can deliver images of protest that reach a global audience. The Battle for Seattle will be remembered as a global media spectacle—a rallying call for anti-globalization political movements worldwide. As such, dissidents utilized another way to attack the global economic order.

    Global Democracy as a Politics of Disturbance

    So far I have suggest-ed that globalization empowers average citizens as much as it disempowers them. Effective protest actions may be able to induce political change at the global level. Dissenting protests may even become a new method of accruing power. Are dissenting protests a new kind of democratic participation, then, and do they make a meaningful contribution to the theory and practice of global democracy?

    When viewed from a traditional, institutional democratic perspective, protest actions do not seem to add a meaningful dimension to democratic deliberations. The situation looks more complex, however, if we push our understanding of democracy beyond an institutionalized framework of procedures, such as holding elections. Anti-globalization protests may then be understood as part of broader, transnational democratic processes.

    In an oppressive political environment, longed-for change will often come not from internal and institutionalized reforms, but from an externally induced politics of disturbance. William Connolly suggests that sometimes “it takes a militant, experimental, and persistent political movement to open up a line of flight from culturally induced suffering.”10 Certainly, democratic participation cannot be fully institutionalized. This is particularly the case in a global context that lacks democratic accountability and intuitions that might anchor and regulate popular participation in decision-making procedures. Regardless of the degree to which any political system has developed democratic procedures, it will necessarily include a structure of exclusion. Public scrutiny ensures the legitimacy of even the most democratically advanced society. This constant revisionist tendency promotes adequate and fair political foundations.

    The anti-globalization movement affirms this revisionist tendency because it makes globalization a constant topic of discussion. Protest actions formed around issues like environmental protection and indigenous rights ensure that these issues remain under scrutiny. Anti-globalization protests challenge what Manfred Steger calls globalism: “a political ideology that endows the concept of globalization with market-oriented norms, values, and meanings.”11 Steger argues that the neoliberal approach to globalization rose to such prominence in the 1990s that its fundamental values were beyond contention. Free trade and market expansion were considered politically benign; they were corollaries to globalization’s economic growth. So imperative were neoliberal norms that alternative development models were considered illegitimate, irrational, or even illusory and thus dismissed as protectionist, socialist, or utopian.12

    The preponderance of anti-globalization dissenting movements and world media coverage of their activities questions the belief that free market economics produce seamless global development. As society debates neo-liberalist ideology and considers other perspectives on globalization, belief in an alternative model is becoming more and more popular. Consider the charter of the World Social Forum, the loose institutional element of the global justice movement, which describes a set of values and goals that promote to a pacifist path of development.13 Although many people dis-agree with this agenda, the salient observation is that the anti-globalization movement has forced advocates of neo-liberalism to actively justify the ideology’s political foundations.

    Towards Global Democratic Accountability

    Important as it is, politics of dissent and disturbance are not enough to establish a new, global form of democracy. Yet, how would we justly define norms and prioritize policies when a society lacks a consensus of political opinion as well as a forum for mediating potential conflicts of interest?

    Although it may be too early to realistically imagine how democracy could work beyond the realm of the state, a contemplation of this scenario demands consideration of dissent as a positive force of globalization.

    What, then, are the practical implications of the conceptual arguments I have presented here? Democratic constituencies must make decision. They need to formulate particular positions and clearly distinguish right from wrong. Often, it is not possible to do so by consensus. Excluding certain views is desirable, even necessary—this is why dissent is inevitable in a democracy. But to keep the decision-making process as fair and transparent as possible, these dissident voices must be heard and taken into account in the deliberation process. Established state-based democracies have well worked out procedures to do so, but such procedures do not yet exist at the global level where power relations are far more prevalent than democratic principles. Multinational companies and international organizations are not run according to traditional principles of democratic accountability. The UN is the only truly global institution where most states have a say, but its decision-making procedures revolve around the veto powers of the Security Council, which is dominated by few powerful nations.

    Given the absence of a global institution that could facilitate and implement democratic ideals, dissent becomes an even more crucial tool in the global society. Dissent is often the only way for disenfranchised people to contribute to global affairs, and thus key actors in international politics must be more attuned to integrating outside dissident voices into their deliberations. Take the issue of climate change: The most powerful international actors, such as the United States, the EU, and China, will inevitably shape the types of policies that are being established and implemented in response to the challenges ahead. But the ensuing framework can only be democratically legitimate if the voices of disenfranchised  people—often  those most affected by climate change—are heard in global deliberations. When this is not the case, dissatisfaction grows until it is so widespread that popular resentment erupts in the form of mass protest, revolutionary upheaval, or a terrorist attack. A functioning democratic system, one that listens to and debates grievances and heeds dissident voices, is far more likely to generate political outcomes capable of avoiding such disruptive and often violent scenarios.

    Order is a necessary precondition for democracy, the rule of law, the provision of human rights, and human civilization itself.

    Appreciating the nexus between dissent and democracy requires rethinking the underlying relationship between order and change.14 Most politicians, diplomats, and philosophers have emphasized the importance of order over the forces that promote change. Existing orders tend to be accepted as good and desirable because they reflect the values and institutions that have emerged slowly over time. Alain Joxe, a fierce critic of current international regimes, asserts, “The most formidable enemy one must face in politics is disorder.” For Joxe, order “is always necessary because it pro-vides protection.”15 Most commentators would agree that order is desirable, if not essential because order is a necessary pre-condition for democracy, the rule of law, the provision of human rights, and human civilization itself.

    But the politics of order and the politics of disturbance are more intricate than they might seem. Many injustices, from domestic abuse to torture and genocide, occur not from a lack of order but under an unjust order. The concentration camps of Nazi Germany did not result from the absence of order, but from the meticulous infatuation with an order—which envisioned a racially “pure” state and was determined to pursue its racial agenda with all requisite action.

    Dissent can occasionally be required to challenge oppressive orders and to promote a more just global society. Doing so is an ongoing process and of particular importance in the current age of globalization, which witnesses sudden and unforeseen events that challenge and transform norms, identities, and values. Addressing the ensuing challenges demands a politics of order and a dissident democratic element capable of critically evaluating the value of competing orders. Institutionalizing this scrutinizing process is unrealistic. This is why a healthy dose of dissent is a beneficial—even essential—component in the search for global democracy.

    ***

    Roland Bleiker is professor of International Politics at the University of Queensland. His pubilcations include Popular Dissent, Human Agency, and Global Politics; Divided Korea: Toward a Culture of Reconciliation; and, as co-editor, Security and the War on Terror. The book Aesthetics and World Politics examines the emotional dimensions of security threats through a range of aesthetic sources, including literature and visual art.

    NOTES

    1. Thanks to Mark Chou and Emma Hutchison for comments on a This essay is an attempt to con-dense, but also further explore work I have previously presented on this topic, most recently in “Visualising Post-National Democracy,” in The New Pluralism: William Connolly and the Contemporary Global Condition, eds. Mort Schoolman and David Campbell, 121-142. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2008.
    2. Richard Falk and Andrew Strauss, “Toward glob-al parliament,” Foreign Affairs 80 (2001): 212-220; David Held, Democracy and Global Order (Oxford: Polity, 1995), 273; Robert E. Goodin, “Global Democracy: In the Beginning” (The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Australia, March 23, 2008).
    3. John Dryzek, Deliberative Democracy and Beyond: Liberals, Critics, Contestations (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000); Jürgen Habermas, Theorie des kommunika-tiven Handelns (Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, 1988).
    4. William Connolly, The Ethos of Pluralization (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1995), 149, 154; Why I am not a Secularist (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1999), 51, 155; Neuropolitics: Thinking, Culture, Speed (Minneapolis: University of Min-nesota Press, 2002), 195-196.
    5. Margaret Levi and David Olson, “The Battles for Seattle,” Politics and Society 3 (September 2000): 325.
    6. 6 Vandana Shiva, “This Round to the Citizens,” The Guardian, August 12,1999.
    7. Most prominently expressed by Thomas Friedman in The Lexus and the Olive Tree (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2000) and The World is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First Century (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2006).
    8. Joan Bondurant, Conquest of Violence: The Gandhi-an Philosophy of Conflict (Berkeley: University of Califor-nia Press, 1967), x.
    9. See, for instance, Robert O’Brien, Anne Marie Goetz, Jan Aart Scholte, and Marc Williams, Contesting Global Governance: Multilateral Economic Institutions and Global Social Movements (Cambridge University Press, 2000), 7; Mark Rupert, “In the Belly of the Beast: Resisting Globalisation and War in a Neo-Imperial Moment,” in Critical Theories, World Politics and the Anti-Globalisation Movement, Catherine Eschle and Bice Maiguashca, 46-47 (London: Routledge, 2005; Ronald J. Deib-ert, “International Plug ‘n Play? Citizen Activism, the Internet and Global Public Policy,” International Studies Perspectives 1.3 (2000): 255-272; Michael Hardt, “Today’s Bandung?“ New Left Review, 14 (March/April 2002):117.
    10. Connolly, Why I am not a Secularist,
    11. Manfred Steger, Globalism: Market Ideology Meets Terrorism (Lanhan: Rowman & Littlefield, 2005), ix.
    12. Steger, Globalism, 8-9.
    13. World Social Forum, “World Social Forum Charter of Principles,” http://www.forumsocial-org.br/main.php?id_menu=4&cd_lan-guage=2 (date accessed March 2008).
    14. See William Connolly, Pluralism (Durham: Duke University Press, 2005), 121-126.
    15. Alain Joxe, Empire of Disorder, Ames Hodges (New York: Semiotext(e), 2002).